Framework
Belief to Knowledge
Inside a single mind
Something that crosses into a mind becomes one of three things: experience, belief, or knowledge. The threshold that matters is the one between belief and knowledge.
Experience, Belief, Knowledge
Experience is raw contact. Something happened and was noticed. Nothing about why or how has been attached to it yet.
Belief is a held claim without causal grounding. It is a mixture, sustained by memorization, repetition, usefulness and social reinforcement, and held together by upkeep. Validity-as-utility operates here: a belief feels valid when it is useful to the person holding it. So does crystallization. Belief is the only tier that needs continuous upkeep to persist. Asymptotic belief is what never crosses out of this tier. It is approached indefinitely, maintained and never resolved.
Knowledge is belief that has reacted: the compound, where belief is the mixture. It doesn't need stirring to remain what it is, because it is tied to the mechanism it is about. Some knowledge goes further. Understanding a mechanism well enough to extend it somewhere it wasn't built for is richer than knowledge that only explains the case it came from. Both sit inside Knowledge. There is no fourth tier above it.
Belief to knowledge is the threshold that matters. Asymptotic belief is the failure: indefinite approach without crossing.
What moves a belief across
The transformation from belief to knowledge can work through physical instantiation: a person acts, and the world answers. Any similar causal coupling does the same work. Correctors and Recruiters calls that event a corrector.
Where no such coupling is in play, the transformation works primarily through identity. Identity is the carrier. It decides what a belief is anchored to, and so whether contact with the world is allowed to test it.
Hard to vary
David Deutsch gives the distinction a test. In The Beginning of Infinity he argues that good explanations are hard to vary, because they are tied to what they explain, and bad ones are easy to vary, because nothing constrains them. Easy-to-vary belief is unreacted. It is held by whatever is convenient and can be swapped without cost, because nothing bonds it to a mechanism. Hard-to-vary knowledge resists substitution, because substitution would break something.
Constructor theory, the source of Possibility Space, says what is physically possible. It doesn't say what is reachable for a given person, or what crosses from belief into knowledge for them. That is a different question, and it is the one this framework takes up.
One system
Identity is a complex system. It has no discrete parts that each handle a separate job. Its properties, mechanisms and functions interact with one another and with other complex systems.
Low permeability and crystallization show up together in it. That looks like a property of how the whole system is organized, and no single component produces it. Correctors and Recruiters gives the mechanism: beliefs that never reacted get anchored to identity, and identity protects what is anchored to it.
Where this connects
Topology sets the space and what lets something cross into a person. The education application follows this same process once an institution runs it at scale.